The Difference Between ASP, SBR, MBR and MBBR Sewage Treatment Plants
Updated: Apr 1, 2021
Let's Comparing Technologies – Conventional ASP , SBR, MBBR, MBR on today.
Welcome to our blog post. In our blog, we will share information about water treatment ,wastewater treatment etc.. the sector news, current developments and new technologies to our valued customers.Please note that as this information may contain copyright, its use without reference may result in a license.You can get updates on business, trends, news and more by following us and have a good trip ....
“Most of Sewage Treatment Plants and Effluent Treatment Plants are installed with conventional activated sludge process as biological treatment unit. However, there are other modified or updated version of biological treatment available in market, since past few years. It is worth to be noted that each of these technologies have their own pros and cons, but the technology can be selected based on technological and financial evaluation for a specific project.”
Conventional activated sludge process (ASP): Process in Brief: Biomass is developed in aeration tank, where air is continuously applied through blower or surface aerator. Wastewater is fed to aeration tank and flow into settling tank known as clarifier, here biomass is allowed to settle and separates from wastewater. Clear water flows outside of clarifier and settled sludge recycled back into aeration tank, known as activated biomass.
o Require more land area compared to other technologies
o Operates on continuous basis
o Simple operation o Cost effective
Sequential Batch Reactor (SBR): Process in Brief: Biomass is developed in SBR tanks- generally operates in dual tank mode, where air is applied through blowers. Operation type is having four stages – Fill, aeration, settling and decantation. Wastewater is filled in tank, aeration is started for a specified period once filled to full level, then aeration stops and allow settling of biomass within tank itself. Once biomass is settled clear supernatant wastewater is decanted and discharged from the system.
o Contains anoxic zone which provide control over denitrification
o Better operation control as operates in batch mode
o Better space management
o Require automation
o Cost is higher than conventional treatment process
o Require two tanks of same size to operate on continuous basis
Moving Bed Bio Reactor (MBBR System): Process in Brief: Biomass is developed on supporting media as biofilms. These media are continuously kept in suspended form by blowing air through blowers. The biofilms developed on supporting media, degrades the pollution load present in wastewater. Generally provided with a settler to separate biomass mixed with wastewater. Clear supernatant of the clarifier – settler is discharged from the system. – is the combination of the membrane process and a biological waste-water treatment process. It is one of the most widely used processes.
o Provide good removal of pollution load.
o Need continuous monitoring of media is required.
o Particularly useful for packaged installation
o Installation Circular tanks are convenient
o More height can be kept for reactor
o Media replacement and checking is little cumbersome
Membrane Bio Reactor (MBR): Process in Brief: Biomass is developed in aeration basin by providing air and nutrients. The mixed liquor is then filtered through battery of membranes either submerged (internal) or side-stream (external). By providing high force of pumps, mixed liquor is filtered and clear filtrated is released from system, while solid part (i.e biomass) is transferred back to aeration basin.
o Mostly runs at higher MLSS level
o Can accept high pollution load as compare to other process
o Compact size due to use membranes and avoiding separate settler
o Does not require tertiary and disinfectant treatment in most cases
o Remarkably high capital cost
o High operation cost
o Sophisticated controlling system required
o Very few players in the market who produce membranes for this application
Reference: ▪ Manual on Sewerage and Sewage Treatment Systems, Central Public Health & Environmental Engineering Organization (CPHEEO), Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, Government of India ▪ US Environmental Protection Agency
mbbr system, wastewater,treatment